Carlton Tavern public inquiry ends - but not without controversy

PUBLISHED: 18:20 25 May 2016 | UPDATED: 10:37 09 June 2016

Friends of the Carlton Tavern demonstrate outside Westminster City Hall  before a public inquiry inside  Pic credit: Polly Hancock

Friends of the Carlton Tavern demonstrate outside Westminster City Hall before a public inquiry inside Pic credit: Polly Hancock


Final submissions for and against the rebuilding of a Kilburn pub unlawfully demolished ended an “unprecedented” public inquiry yesterday.

Carlton Tavern pub demolishedCarlton Tavern pub demolished

The inquiry into the Carlton Tavern in Carlton Vale reduced to rubble by developer’s CLTX was not without controversy.

The five-day inquiry centred on the planning refusal before the pub was reduced to rubble last April and also the council’s enforcement order to rebuild it which followed, both appealed by CLTX.

Saira Kabir Sheikh, QC for Westminster Council, said CLTX’s planning consultant Kieran Rafferty could not be treated as a “credible or bonefide” witness having lied to the inquiry about his qualifications and membership of the Royal Town Planning Institute (RTPI).

Mr Rafferty told the inquiry last week that he would apply for membership, but he was forced to tell Ms Kabir Sheikh he had not done so.

The pub before it was demolished (Pic credit: Flickr/Ewan Munro)The pub before it was demolished (Pic credit: Flickr/Ewan Munro)

He also had to admit he misled a referee who wrote him a “glowing reference” for his application, by not mentioning his cross examination last Friday.

Members of the public shouted “charleton” as Friends of Carlton Tavern (FOCT) campaigners gave their final submissions.

Stephen Wilcox, a former government lawyer, criticised CLTX owner Ori Calif, who did not give testimony at the hearing. He said: “The appellant knew planning permission to demolish had been refused and that listing of the premises was a possibility but decided to take matters into his own hands to avoid the financial implications of the premises being listed. The appeal against enforcement order should be refused.”

Robin Banks, of Essendine Road, said the case had to “act as a deterrent” to other companies. “It should deter potential criminals from violating the law so that the rest shall hear and be daunted.”

Ms Kabir Sheikh said in her closing statement: “The appellant should be required to rebuild the Carlton Tavern. No cogent reason has been advanced by the appellant why the notice should not be upheld other than what can only be inferred as a desire not to do so in order to reap the commercial rewards of its unlawful actions.”

Rupert Warren QC, for CLTX, said the weight given to Mr Rafferty’s “views on planning matters” was “for the inspector”. He added: “The community use on the site has, it should not be forgotten, already gone through two evolutions, a 19th century and a 20th century pub. The planning appeal scheme would provide a 21st century pub, but with the substantial land use advantages of co-location with housing.”

Graham Dudley, the planning inspector, gave seven weeks for the decision to be made.

Related articles

Latest Kilburn & Brent News Stories

Yesterday, 08:00

.This response is typical of the sort of excuse that Brent’s planners come up with, writes Philip Grant, Kingsbury (full address supplied), in response to an e-mail from Brent Council’s planning team about his Wembley Stadium concerns (“Stadium view is vanishing”, Times):

Saturday, October 13, 2018

Once again, politicians are changing our wards to suit themselves, not our


Friday, October 12, 2018

The third anniversary of a Kingsbury man’s fatal stabbing has been marked by his grieving mother carrying a sandwich board with his alleged killer’s face on it.

Friday, October 12, 2018

A Willesden Green mum whose daughter battled self-harm has spoken about the hard-hitting photo exhibition she produced to raise awareness of the problem.

Friday, October 12, 2018

The stories of Irish and Pakistani migrant communities who came to Cricklewood have come to life in a new project.

Thursday, October 11, 2018

Hundreds of people looking for a new career headed to Wembley Park to try their luck at a job fair.

Thursday, October 11, 2018

A Kilburn councillor sacked from his role on Brent’s planning committee “for making the wrong decisions” has had his complaints against the council leader thrown out.

Thursday, October 11, 2018

Two men have been charged following an armed raid on a watch shop in Brent Cross Shopping Centre.


A new community centre, The Yellow, opens in Wembley Park in the heart of the Brent community. From October 1, the hub will offer a selection of arts and fitness classes, many of which will be free.

The Granville has begun taking bookings for workspaces and events ahead of its opening this spring.

Brent Clinical Commissioning Group has announced changes to the community’s cardiology service.

Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now

Newsletter Sign Up

Kilburn Times twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most Read Kilburn News

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Brent & Kilburn Times
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now