Cricklewood surgeon wins case for unfair dismissal

PUBLISHED: 13:31 10 December 2015 | UPDATED: 13:43 10 December 2015

Nadey Hakim won his case for unfair dismissal

Nadey Hakim won his case for unfair dismissal


A leading surgeon has spoken of his delight after winning his case for unfair dismissal against an NHS Trust.

Pioneering transplant surgeon Nadey Hakim, 57, from Hocroft Road, on the Hocroft Estate in Cricklewood, had been dismissed from his post at Hammersmith Hospital in February accused of gross misconduct.

He was said to have “sacrificed” the needs of a woman undergoing a kidney and pancreas transplant at Hammersmith Hospital by first performing a live kidney swap between two brothers at Bupa’s private Cromwell Hospital.

Employment Judge Sarah Goodman yesterday found in his favour after a week-long tribunal against Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, which runs Hammersmith Hospital.

Judge Goodman said: “It sometimes happens that clinicians make errors of judgment. If all clinicians were dismissed for an error of judgement then hospitals would be depleted of their staff.”

The tribunal had heard that the woman patient, now 43, was cured of diabetes that she had had since 18. Both brothers also made a full recovery.

Prof Hakim, who performed London’s first pancreas transplant at Hammersmith 20 years ago and has raised £3.5 million in research grants for Imperial, now has to wait until another hearing on January 11 to learn whether the judge will order him to be given his job back.

He had been suspended in September 2014 and then sacked in February this year after being reported for the way he arranged the private and NHS operations to take place simultaneously on October 18, 2013.

Junior doctors transplanted the woman’s kidney and Prof Hakim did her pancreas four-and-a-half hours after the operation began, after completing the kidney transplant on the brothers at the Cromwell Hospital, in Earl’s Court.

The tribunal heard concerns from Imperial about the 25 hours the pancreas was “kept on ice” and that it was transplanted “in the wrong order” - after the kidney.

Judge Goodman accepted that Prof Hakim had been unaware of the 25-hour timeframe, and that he had arranged for NHS colleagues to cover his absence.

A spokesman for Prof Hakim said last night: “At the heart of this case are two patients who were each in need of life saving transplant surgery. There has never been any question that the outcome of each operation performed by Prof Hakim was extremely successful.

“Professor Hakim’s priority was to ensure that each of these patients received the care they needed in an area of surgery dependent on the unpredictable availability of donor organs.

“Professor Hakim determined that both operations should take place concurrently to give each of these patients the best chance of success. The fact that one was a private patient and another an NHS patient played absolutely no part in the judgements made.”

He added: “Professor Hakim is delighted that the Employment Judge in this case found that he was unfairly dismissed.” and he “remains passionate about the NHS.”

Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust spokeswoman said: “We are disappointed by the judge’s ruling and we are considering our position.”

Related articles

Latest Kilburn & Brent News Stories

Yesterday, 14:34

There are severe delays on the Jubilee Line after a person was hit by a train in Neasden.

Yesterday, 11:45

An abandoned cat brought into Mayhew nearly three years ago has finally found a permanent home with a former Eastenders star.

Yesterday, 10:02

Two Wembley drug dealers have been jailed after one of them was found to have crack cocaine and heroin in his poo.

Yesterday, 09:30

Brent Council has been accused of social cleansing by one of its own councillors as 197 households are forced to leave two blocks in Kilburn.

Wed, 15:37

Wembley Stadium is no longer for sale after billionaire Fulham FC owner deemed the move “too divisive”.

Wed, 12:15

Library campaigners in Cricklewood got a big surprise and welcome boost with a charitable windfall of more than £100,000.

Wed, 10:48

A Harlesden shop that sold a 16cm boning knife to two 15-year-olds has been fined more than £1,700.

Wed, 10:15

The parents of two murdered teenage boys have got behind a new campaign by Brent Council urging youths not to carry knives.


A new community centre, The Yellow, opens in Wembley Park in the heart of the Brent community. From October 1, the hub will offer a selection of arts and fitness classes, many of which will be free.

The Granville has begun taking bookings for workspaces and events ahead of its opening this spring.

Brent Clinical Commissioning Group has announced changes to the community’s cardiology service.

Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now

Newsletter Sign Up

Kilburn Times twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most Read Kilburn News

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Brent & Kilburn Times
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now